When it comes to puppy housetraining, one of the biggest decisions new dog owners face is whether to use a crate or puppy pads. Many individuals who are new to dogs may initially feel hesitant about using a crate for their puppies. The idea of confining their new furry friend feels wrong or cruel. However, this reluctance often disappears after a few days of living with a new pet when they realize that dog crates actually make life easier for both the owner and the dog.
It is a wise decision to introduce your dog to a crate for various reasons, including vet visits, travel, recovery from illness, and safety. But understanding HOW and WHY crates work for housetraining is crucial to using them effectively.
Understanding Crate Training: The Science Behind It
Dogs are naturally den animals and will instinctively seek out a small, secure space for themselves, whether or not you provide one. This makes it relatively simple to train your dog to love their crate. The concept behind using a crate for housetraining is based on a fundamental fact: dogs are naturally clean creatures and dislike having a urine-soaked rug in their living area, just like you do.
When you use a properly-sized crate, your puppy’s natural instinct to keep their sleeping area clean actually WORKS FOR YOU. Your puppy will resist soiling their crate because that’s where they sleep and feel safe. This biological reality makes crate training one of the most effective housetraining tools available.
Choosing the Right Crate Size
This is where many new owners make critical mistakes. It is crucial that the crate is the appropriate size — just big enough for the dog to lie down, stand up, and turn around comfortably. NOT bigger.
If the crate is too large, the dog may feel that it is acceptable to use one corner for elimination and then settle down in a clean area. You’ve defeated the purpose of the crate entirely.
This is why a MidWest Wire Dog Crate with Divider is the perfect starter crate — the divider lets you adjust the size as your puppy grows so you only ever need one crate. As your puppy gets bigger, you simply move the divider. This is also more cost-effective than buying multiple crates.
Many crates come with partitions that allow you to adjust the size as your puppy grows. If your crate doesn’t have a divider, you can create one using:
- Cardboard boxes
- Plywood panels
- DIY dividers
- Even towels taped securely
The key is making the space small enough that your puppy feels it’s their den.
Reading Your Puppy’s Signals
When your puppy feels the urge to relieve themselves, they will usually communicate this to you through whining and scratching. This is their way of signaling that they need to go and want to be let out of their crate. These signals are GOLD — they tell you exactly when your puppy needs to go outside.
Common pre-elimination signals include:
- Whining or barking
- Scratching at the crate door
- Pacing
- Sniffing the ground
- Circling
- Getting restless
It is important not to delay when you hear these signals. The moment your puppy whines, take them outside IMMEDIATELY. Even 30 seconds of delay can result in an accident.
Allowing your puppy to lose control in their crate may lead them to believe that it is acceptable to soil their living space. This can result in them leaving messes around your home as well. More importantly, it creates negative associations with the crate, making them hate it instead of love it.
When Accidents Happen: Cleanup Strategy
When accidents happen keep Rocco & Roxie Stain & Odor Eliminator on hand — it breaks down odors completely at the molecular level so your puppy won’t return to the same spot. This is essential whether you’re using crates or pads, because odor management is critical to success.
Dogs can smell urine residue long after you think the area is clean. Enzyme cleaners are the ONLY products that actually break down the compounds causing the smell.
The Puppy Pad Debate: When Pads Make Sense
The use of puppy pads and paper training can be a bit tricky because it reinforces two different options for the puppy. Ideally, puppies should learn to hold their bladder indoors and only eliminate at designated spots outdoors. Your goal should be ONE approved bathroom location — outside.
However, there are certain situations that may require some creative thinking:
When Puppy Pads Are Appropriate:
- Single-income households with long work days — Individuals who have jobs that prevent them from coming home multiple times a day need a backup plan. If you work 10-hour days and your puppy can only hold it 4 hours, pads give them an approved indoor option while you’re gone.
- Small breeds — Small dogs in harsh winter conditions (extreme cold, snow, ice) sometimes benefit from pads. Getting a Chihuahua to go outside in a blizzard is genuinely difficult.
- Senior dogs or medical issues — Dogs with medical conditions may need indoor bathroom options.
- Apartment living — Some apartment dwellers use pads temporarily during training.
Amazon Basics Potty Training Pads provide a designated spot for a dog to relieve themselves at home — they’re leak proof, quick drying and come in packs of 50 and 100 so you’re never caught short. Some pads have attractant scents that encourage puppies to use them.
There are even high-tech indoor dog bathrooms available that are suitable for male dogs as well. These are basically indoor potty boxes that collect waste and are easier to clean than regular pads.
Combining Strategies for Success
Many successful puppy owners use a COMBINATION approach:
- Crate during work hours (preventing accidents)
- Pads in a designated area for emergencies
- Frequent outdoor potty breaks when home
- Consistent schedule and rewards
This gives puppies options while still teaching them that outdoor elimination is preferred.
The Outdoor Essential
Whatever training method you choose, Earth Rated Poop Bags are an essential for every dog owner — thick, leak proof and biodegradable. Always clean up immediately after your puppy eliminates outside. This teaches responsibility and prevents your puppy from thinking that spot is a bathroom again.
Crates vs. Pads: The Bottom Line
Choose Crates if:
- You can be home frequently
- You have time for multiple daily potty breaks
- You want the fastest housetraining timeline
- You want to prevent ALL indoor accidents
Choose Pads if:
- You work long hours
- You have a small breed in harsh winters
- You need a temporary solution
- Your dog has medical issues requiring indoor access
The Truth: Crates work FASTER for housetraining. Pads work BETTER for real-life situations where you can’t always be home. The most successful approach uses BOTH strategically.
With patience, consistency, and the right tools, virtually every puppy can be housetrained. Choose the method that fits your lifestyle, stay consistent, and celebrate every success along the way.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click a link and make a purchase I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I genuinely believe in.